First Time

Winter party
Freezing basement
Smoking in my car while your friends were getting wasted
We’d already started before anybody got there
Your boyfriend was in Florida, failing college, painting lawn chairs

You were crying when I turned on the dome light
Felt like you’d been holding out on me for a long time
Saw the way you got us here alone, and the mood’s right
In just a couple hours, we would kiss for the first time
Kiss for the first time
La-da-da

Now I see you when I’m waking up
So I’m constantly reminded of
The only girl I’ve ever loved
I was lying to the other ones (lying to the other ones)

‘Cause we’re God-tier even on our worst nights
Even got a diamond ring, and like your eyes it shines bright
I can tell you anything, and we don’t even have fights
Even when I kiss you now, it feels just like the first time
Feels just like the last time

La-da-da